080822 Idealization

(August 22, 2008) Every morning, I take a five mile walk around the perimeter of Schollenberger Park. It’s a wetlands area with 200 varieties of bird. This morning, I saw a juvenile mountain lion.

I am a huge fan of tropical birds and love big white flying things. The park obliges me with swans, herons, egrets and American Pelicans. Daily visits give me a growing inisght into the behavior of a range of species.

One of the interesting things that I have been learning is that birds imitate each other. In some cases, herons eat in ways that are characteristic of pelicans. Though one species is known for a certain behavior, a different bird will do the exact same thing under some circumstances. Crows act like hawks when the wind is right.

The other thing I notice is my tendency to idealize. I like to imagine perfect instances of the wildlife I encounter. I’m always somewhat surprised when the reality is a little (or a lot) different.

The ducks around Schollengerger are a great example. They line the banks of the pond. When they swim, it’s a graceful paddle. I never cease to be astonished when I hear the slurping noises in the paddy-like parts of the marsh. These lovely little creatures feed themselves by wallowing in the mud, mouth first. They scoop it up, gargle with it and spray it out.

I prefer my more idyllic version.

American Pelicans are beautiful from afar. Pure white elegance with an orange bill and distinct black markings on the wings (you can only see it when they fly), they are fun to watch and imagine.

Up close, things are a little nastier. These are water birds. Their fathers, always damp, are smelly and dirty. They, too, scoop mud in search of a bug or two. An older Pelican tends to have the most unlovely charateristics of a worn out teddy bear.

Still, when I look, the first thing I see is my idealized version.

In Recruiting, we tend to idealize both jobs and candidates.

Great writers are often unpleasnt cubicle mates. Brilliant workers rarely make effective managers. Great managers predictably have monstrous egos. Well appointed offices can feel like prisons. Certain desirable traits always have a balancing set of the undesirable. Really nice people are often terrible at their jobs.

But, we skip and jump happily through the selection process acting as if the beautiful Pelican  is the bird we’re moving into the bedroom. Sometimes, we even try to run background checks to make sure that it isn’t smelly.

One Response to “080822 Idealization”

  1. The Ornithologist | Amitai Givertz's Recruitomatic Blog Says:

    […] Sumser has taken up bird-spotting. In a pastoral post aptly titled Idealization John shares what he has learned about the fowl and the foul in his circumnavigation of […]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Stay up-to-date with recruiting news and johnsumser.com:

E-mail:

Name:

Company:

November 20, 2008
081121 Recruiting Links (Nov 21, 2008)

Thought for the Day: “Today’s trend is tomorrow’s folly”

SearchWiki: Make Search Your Own
From the official Google blog comes an approach to search that will eliminate the impact of SEO/SEM. In the long haul, building relationships will trump gaming the search engines. Be careful of the way you allocate your resources. Today’s trend is tomorrow’s […]

Read More

081120 Recruiting Tech Links (Nov 20, 2008)

Thought for the Day: “Recruiting leads to winners and losers” - Steve Levy

Teenagers’ Internet Socializing Not a Bad Thing
Imagine it’s sometime during the early 1700s.  Printing presses are just becoming commonplace. Primitive versions of newspapers start to emerge. Here’s a sample headline: “New Teenage Fad, Reading, Not a Bad Thing”  Here’s the story from the […]

Read More
November 19, 2008
Population Distribution Diagrams Redeux

I asked my good friend, Heather Bussing, to try to restate the last article. I want to be sure that I am communicating the idea clearly. Having another person reframe the same thing is a really good way to make sure that the idea is being effectively delivered.
Here is her version of yesterday’s article:
John Sumser […]

Read More

Population Distribution Diagrams: The Project II

Population Distribution Diagrams: Definitions
(Nov 19, 2008)Population Distributions Defined
There’s a pretty length series of discussions about Population Distribution Diagrams (PDDs) in the archives. (There’s also a list of  links at the end of this piece).
In a nutshell, PDDs are graphs that show how a group of people are distributed along the lines of calendar age, tenure […]

Read More
November 18, 2008
081119 Daily Links (Nov 19, 2008)

Thought For The Day: "We are in the middle of a data explosion that changes everything. It used to be cheap, now it’s plentiful."
Microsoft Plans Free Software To Shield PCs "Free" has just begun. Maybe if MSFT acts like they own their problems for a change, their credibility will return.
The Real Dan Lyons bails on […]

Read More

Population Distribution Diagrams: The Project I

(Nov 18, 2008)
The Problem
Hiring is almost always reactive, transactional and shortsighted. Even the best hiring environments rarely consider the aggregate impact of an individual hire. Relatively few organizations provide guidance beyond platitudes about the strategic meaning of any given position.
Before automation and the various management technologies of the 80s and 90s, service functions within the […]

Read More

081118 Recruiting Links (Nov 18, 2008)

Thought For The Day: "When giving a public science lecture to a general audience, there will always be one weirdo who asks questions that have nothing to do with your lecture. There will also be one smart-aleck who asks questions to show how smart he is. The faster you silence both of them, the happier […]

Read More
November 17, 2008
The Rise of the Recruiting Celebrities

Idiot Savants
(November 17, 2008) Today’s piece is a response to a deliciously funny article by my good friend Ami Givertz. In “Speaking In Tongues“, Ami compares charismatic snake charmers and healers with the current crop of celebrities in the Recruiting Industry.
Josh Kahn makes similar points in his article “Caveat Lector“. Josh is at the opposite […]

Read More
November 16, 2008
081117 Talent Management Links (Nov 17, 2008)

Thought For the Day: Once you begin to believe your own resume, you will not be happy with your current job or salary.
Talent Management Functions Like the Kidney that Hires the Good Personnel and FiresInspired by a piece of email that featured quotes from "What is the Color of your Parachute" and the idea that […]

Read More
November 14, 2008
081114 Daily Links (Nov 14, 2008)

Thought For the Day: Focus, focus, focus

Google Finally Starts Firing Slackers?
“Recent change in behavior here at Google… it used to be nearly impossible to get fired for general underperformance, but about a week ago word went out to managers that this was a good time to get rid of any people who were underperforming.”
A scientific […]

Read More